Another advantage of free choice (Extended Abstract)

Paper: Another advantage of free choice (Extended Abstract). Michael Ben-Or. 1983

High level protocol idea

  • Protocol proceeds in rounds
  • Every round we check if we have \((n+t)/2+1\) messages for the same value.
    • If we do, output it but continue
    • Else, if there is a value that \(t+1\) nodes support use that for future rounds
    • Else, set a random value
  • If a node decides, all nodes will set the decided value in future, and therefore the remaining honest nodes will also eventually decide the same value
  • The protocol guarantees termination if there is no initial consensus, since nodes will randomly choose values until they are at consensus.

Protocols

This paper presents a consensus protocol.

Async.

  • Protocol in Theorem 1: Tolerates \(t
  • Protocol in Theorem 2: Tolerates \(t
  • Expected exponential running time
  • Trick: Set \(t=O(\sqrt{n})\) to make the running time constant

Sync.

  • Tolerates \(t=O(\sqrt{n})\) Byzantine faults
  • Constant expected running time

Notes

  • This paper points out that consensus is impossible for \(n \le 2t\).
  • This paper also shows how a randomized algorithm can do better than the \(t+1\) round bound by Dolev and Reischuk.

References

Michael Ben-Or. 1983. “Another advantage of free choice (Extended Abstract).” https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/800221.806707.